Politics for the People March Column on IVN

Memoir Gives First-Hand Account of the Real Crises on the Southern Border

IVN Logo
Originally posted on IVN
By Cathy Stewart


Since the New Year, I have been reading a steady diet of memoirs. The genre has captivated me since working with my 93-year-old father to finish his memoir, Hilltop Echoes, about growing up on a farm in rural Massachusetts. His book explores family secrets, the joys of a secret trout fishing spot, the loss of his beloved father, moving off the farm and entering the Marines… all told against the backdrop of the New England countryside.

On the memoir road these last two months, I have met Tara Westover’s EducatedInheritance: A Memoir of Genealogy, Paternity and Love by Dani Shapiro; Michelle Obama’s Becoming; and Deep Creek: Finding Hope in the High Country by Pam Houston. I recommend all four. The fifth memoir is a stand out: The Line Becomes A River by Francisco Cantú.

With the partisan debate about immigration and the wall, I realized I knew little about what our 1,954-mile southern border is like for the people desperately trying to cross it in hopes of a better life, and the agents who patrol it.

Francisco Cantú, a third-generation Mexican American, became a Border Agent after college at the age of 23 and served for four years. His book gives us a nonlinear, at times poetic, account of his experiences — of the desert, the thirst, the desperation of those trying to cross into the US seeking a better life, the roles of the cartels and gangs that prey on people looking for safe passage, and the often dehumanizing tactics of the U.S. Border Patrol.

In an essay in the New York Review of Books, Francisco says, “When I began writing, I knew that the book must be anchored by an exploration of the myriad ways violence becomes normalized along the border.”

The book follows the author’s time as an agent along the border and later as an intelligence officer. Francisco began to suffer from nightmares and frequent teeth grinding, and many second thoughts about his role. As his mother reminds him, “You can’t exist within a system for that long without being implicated, without absorbing its poison.”

The third section of the book tells of Francisco’s friendship (while a graduate student) with José, who travels back to Mexico to visit his dying mother and is captured and arrested as he tries to return. Francisco stands with his friend and José’s family as they go through the process and see their beloved husband and father deported.

In one of the final chapters of the book, José tells Francisco that he will continue to attempt to cross, no matter the risk: “I will do anything to be on the other side. To be honest, I would rather be in prison in the U.S. and see my boys once a week through the glass than to stay here and be separated from my family…”

The Line Becomes A River is a haunting memoir about the people on the border and the desert and the shadows that make it hard for us all to see one another. It’s about much of what is missing in the partisan conversation about immigration and “the wall.” Can we break down the partisan walls enough to let the actual people on the border, both sides of it, inform our conversations?


Cathy L. Stewart has been a political activist in the independent movement since the mid-1980s. She is the Vice President for National Development at Independent Voting and the founder and host of Politics for the People.



The Line Becomes a River will be our next P4P selection.

Our conference call with author Franciso Cantú will by Sunday, June 2nd at 7 pm EST.

Politics for the People December Column on IVN

IVN Logo

REVIEW: Jon Meacham’s “The Soul of America” Gives Americans a Much Needed History Lesson

Here’s a passage that brings historians’ public value to life: “The only way to come to understanding is by knowing the history that has shaped us,” writes Jon Meacham in his evocative, The Soul of America (p. 259).
What Meacham asserts is profound. What appears to be new in America’s politics is often anything but. A more likely description, Meacham contends, is that it’s the newest episode of ‘America’s eternal struggle.’
“I’ve wondered why the next generation can’t profit from the generation before,” Meacham quotes a flummoxed Harry Truman. “But they it never does until people get knocked in the head by experience.” (p. 259)
So true: Live it and know it. But let’s wish it were otherwise. If Americans could actually learn from history and practice accordingly—especially now, living as we are, in the Age of Trump—we’d be so much better off as a nation.But they don’t. And that’s what makes this book so important: Meacham tells many Americans ‘what they never knew.’

If history were truly our guide, then each and every time we scream—“Trump! There he goes again! –we’d appreciate what may be the most poignant passage of Meacham’s book: “And yet and yet—there is always an ‘and yet’ in American history.” (p. 103, bolding added)

America’s script, Meacham argues, is a constant yin and yang—of taking two steps forward (sometimes one) and one step back (sometimes two). He describes it as “the war between the ideal and the real, between what’s right and what’s convenient, between the larger good and personal interest” (p. 7).

Each American president engages in that very same struggle. For example, LBJ exerted moral leadership when he signed The Civil Rights Act—knowing full well that he was likely signing over the South to the Republican Party. Richard Nixon showed a very different temperament—and paid a steep price—when he conspired in Watergate.

Then there was Andrew Jackson, the president who took a Hobbesian view of the presidency (that is, every single day is a war). Jackson, whom Meacham describes as “the most contradictory of men,” ”spoke passionately of the needs of the humble members of society…and made the case for a more democratic understanding of power.” But he (also) “massacred Native Americans in combat, executed enemy soldiers, and imposed martial law” (p. 29), while constantly blaming others and expressing self-pity with regularity.

I’ve come to see Woodrow Wilson—once my presidential hero—in that contradictory way, too. Wilson led America during the era of suffrage triumph and argued vociferously for what eventually became the United Nations. But he also squelched free speech through The Sedition Act (1918) and was adamant about keeping African Americans out of government (they don’t have ‘the intelligence,’ he surmised).

Thank goodness we had activists then (as we have today) that got into Wilson’s face and fought him every step of the way. Alice Paul (my new hero) is one example.

But neither Jackson nor Wilson—add Nixon to that list, too—was a one-off. “If we expect trumpets to sound unwavering notes,” Meacham observes, “we will be disappointed. The past tells us that politics is an uneven symphony” (p. 103).

Consider this: for all the great things FDR did for America, keep in mind that he interred Japanese-, German-, and Italian-Americans during WWII. And he wouldn’t support anti-lynching legislation—despite Eleanor’s constant urging—concerned that he’d lose Congressional votes for his New Deal.

Of course, many of us would trade Wilson or FDR for Donald Trump in a heartbeat. Trump—an extreme version of the losing side of what Jon Meacham calls, “the battle for our better angels”—is the reason he wrote this book: “I am writing now,” Meacham scribes, “not because past American presidents have always risen to the occasion but because the incumbent American president so rarely does,” p. 13).

But staying true to the theme of this important book, Meacham doesn’t see Trump as unique. In many ways, he’s a 21st Century version of that damnable 20th Century figure, Senator Joe McCarthy.

It’s a valid comparison, too. “Our fate (as a society) is contingent upon which element—hope or fear—emerges triumphant,” Meacham writes (p. 7). Lincoln and Obama exuded hope. McCarthy and Trump peddled fear. That’s why—to better understand Trump—it’s advisable to learn more about McCarthy.

“He (McCarthy) exploited the privileges of power and prominence without regard to its responsibilities,” Meacham writes. “A freelance performer who grasped what many ordinary Americans feared,” McCarthy knew that “the country feared Communism…and he fed those fears…. A master of false charges, of conspiracy-tinged rhetoric, McCarthy could distract the public, play the press, and change the subject—all while keeping himself at center stage.” (p. 185)

Sound familiar? Well, there’s more. Even after McCarthy was disgraced publicly, polls showed that 34% of Americans still supported him (p. 201). And McCarthy’s primary advisor—Roy Cohn—later advised a young, New York real estate developer … named Donald Trump (p. 206).

What does Meacham’s work mean for independents? For an answer, I recommend reading the book’s conclusion, “The First Duty of an American Citizen” (p. 255-272). In it, he offers a recipe for response—and two of five ingredients speak directly to what it means to be Independent.

Respect facts and deploy reason: Being able to uncover facts, weigh facts, and come to a reasonable conclusion requires cognitive skills and stick-to-itiveness. It also requires the capacity to disassociate claims from claimants, especially claimants who masquerade as Pied Pipers. To do otherwise, Meacham writes, “is to preemptively surrender the capacity of the mind” (p. 268). The take-away message: think independently.

Resist tribalism: “Wisdom generally comes from a free exchange of ideas, and there can be no free exchange of ideas if everybody on your side already agrees with one another,” Meacham observes (p. 268). Put another way, ‘following the party line’ has costs—not only in terms of constraining the idea pool, but by infecting the public domain with (what I call) the politics of affiliation. To wit: you must go along to get along, especially if you want to get ahead in the party. The take-away message: act independently.

The bottom line is that Jon Meacham’s book is an important read—especially today. Yes, today is probably another chapter in what Meacham calls our ‘eternal struggle,’ but it’s an especially ornery one. To address it effectively, we must learn from the past. But that’s no small order in a society where a lot of folks don’t read much or at all; don’t engage in multifaceted political dialogue much or at all; and get a good share of their news (if not all of it) from friends, social media, and 24-hour ‘news’ networks.

Sadly, there isn’t a lot of depth, understanding, and perceptivity across America today. That makes it easy for the public to be duped, and duping opened the door for Donald Trump.

But duping doesn’t serve democracy—not the kind the Founding Fathers had in mind; not the kind you embrace; and not the kind America needs to be that “Shining City on the Hill” Reagan referenced during his valedictory (1989).

It would be a mistake, though, to conclude that the character of our nation rests solely—even primarily—on the back of the person in The White House. Meacham, among others (Ralph Waldo Emerson, too), believes that it rests with the character of the people (p. 40).

Character. Leading for the public good.

The time is now. The stakes are high. There aren’t alternatives, Eternal Struggle or not.

Politics for the People Book Club Recordings — A Conversation with Dr. Elisabeth Rosenthal

AmSick__StewartRosenthal (1)

On Sunday, December 2nd the book club had the pleasure of spending an hour in conversation with Dr. Elisabeth Rosenthal, the author of An American Sickness: How Healthcare Became Big Business and How You Can Take It Back. You can listen to our full conversation at the end of this post.

Dr. Rosenthal is a graduate of Stanford University and Harvard Medical School.  Dr. Rosenthal practiced emergency medicine before joining the New York Times where she was a senior writer. She is currently editor-in-chief of Kaiser Health News, an independent non-profit DC-based newsroom focusing on health and health policy.

In the introduction of the call, you can hear Dr. Rosenthal and P4P founder and host, Cathy Stewart, discuss Dr. Rosenthal’s journey from the emergency room to writing about healthcare reform, thinking she would one day be able to return to her calling as a doctor. Twenty years later, Dr. Rosenthal decided to write An American Sickness and told us that in working on the book she “…dug into each area of healthcare to see for myself really how it came to be that we put profit on the front burner and health on the back burner.”

Give a listen here or below:


Steve Hough of Florida Fair and Open Primaries kicked us off by asking what Dr. Rosenthal’s views were on the demand for the U.S. to move to a single-payer healthcare system. You can hear Dr. Rosenthal’s response and how she feels that the solution to our healthcare crisis is a political decision here or below.  On the role of the insurance industry, Dr. Rosenthal thinks “…much of what we get from the insurance world, or from a lot of the layers in our healthcare system, has nothing to do with health care, it adds layers of complexity and cost…”


Our next question came from Cynthia Carpathios of Independent Ohio. Cynthia asked about part two of Dr. Rosenthal’s book—Diagnosis and Treatment: Prescriptions for Taking Back Our Healthcare—specifically how she sees us changing the culture of healthcare and how can we transform our healthcare system into one where patient care is the primary concern. Listen here.


Harriet Hoffman of New York, a consultant who helps people understand the Medicare system and make the best, most cost-effective and access-friendly decisions, raised the push by some for ‘Medicare for All.’ She asked if Dr. Rosenthal thinks a ‘Medicare for All’ system would be viable or even desirable as it is now. Hear her answer or check it out below.


Dr. Jessie Fields pointed out that though the healthcare industry spends $3 trillion a year, our life expectancy is going down in the United States. Dr. Fields went on to talk about how the medical industry is the country’s biggest lobbying force, which requires political reform and the removal of profit incentives from healthcare. Despite all of this, Dr. Fields asked Dr. Rosenthal what glimmers of change she can see. An enlightening discussion followed where Dr. Rosenthal shared her view that “…there’s great hope for a kind of physician-patient alliance to bring change.”


Reverend Carl McCluster, an independent organizer in Connecticut, spoke of how many of his parishioners are suffering from high medical and drug costs. Reverend McCluster asked Dr. Rosenthal for three suggested steps that advocates could take to push back against the medical industry. Listen to how to fight back here.


Susan Massad, a retired physician and a clinician educator of over fifty years, worked with young physicians on their listening skills and their abilities to respond to patients. Susan asked if there are things that Dr. Rosenthal thinks patients should be doing that will amplify their voices and could be helpful to challenge the system. Hear the response.


Cathy and Dr. Rosenthal wrapped up the conversation on a note of hope for change and reform. “I tell everyone when I go talk to hospitals,” Dr. Rosenthal said, “just do something. Do something in whatever space you exist to start changing things because I think that’s how empowerment starts.”


You can listen to our entire conversation below:


For easy reference, from An American Sickness:

Dr. Rosenthal’s

Economic Rules of the Dysfunctional Medical Market

  1. More treatment is always better. Default to the most expensive option.
  2. A lifetime of treatment is preferable to a cure.
  3. Amenities and marketing matter more than good care.
  4. As technologies age, prices can rise rather than fall.
  5. There is no free choice. Patients are stuck. And they’re stuck buying American.
  6. More competitors vying for business doesn’t mean better prices; it can drive prices up, not down.
  7. Economies of scale don’t translate to lower prices. With their market power, big providers can simply demand more.
  8. There is no such thing as a fixed price for a procedure or test. And the uninsured pay the highest prices of all.
  9. There are no standards for billing. There’s money to be made in billing for anything and everything.
  10. Prices will rise to whatever the market will bear.


We will announce our next selection soon.


Reminder: P4P Conference Call with Dr. Rosenthal TONIGHT!

AmSick__StewartRosenthal (1)



Join us on a conference call with
An American Sickness Author Elisabeth Rosenthal

Sunday, December 2nd
at 7 pm EST

Call in and Join the Conversation  

Phone number: 641-715-3605   

Passcode: 767775#


Reader’s Forum — Lou Hinman and Jeff Aron

Lou Hinman 


The runaway inflation in the cost of living in America is worst in precisely those sectors of the economy that the 99% can’t live without — higher education, housing, and healthcare. In An American Sickness, Dr. Elisabeth Rosenthal describes in excruciating detail how American healthcare has been hijacked.

How did this happen?  How did we Americans get so divided that a plastic surgeon dares to bill $50,000 for 3 stitches – just one of the many examples that Dr. Rosenthal sites.  (I also read a story not long ago in the New York Times about an “out-of-network” surgeon who ambushed an unsuspecting patient, sewing him up after his operation, and then billing him for a quarter of a million dollars!)

Medicare has become a vast, publicly owned resource  – a huge accumulation of money, automatically withheld from the paychecks of working people for their entire working lives – that is ripe for systematic looting by private interests.  In exactly the same way, private insurance companies don’t complain about extortion by the drug companies, and the newly privatized “not-for-profit” hospitals and their incorporated medical practices, because they can pass the extortionate billing on to their tens of millions of subscribers – you and me.

The corruption of the American system of healthcare has become institutionalized.  Indeed, our healthcare system now fits Irving Goffman’s description of a “total institution” – an institution that, whatever its original or nominal purpose, has as it’s real priority perpetuating itself and benefiting its hangers-on.  Such total institutions are, as Dr. Rosenthal suggests, a sign of a culture in decline.

When President Eisenhower left office in 1961, he warned us about what he called the “military-industrial complex.” In the decades that followed, military production did, in fact, become a juggernaut of profit-making for private interests and, simultaneously, an institutionalized parasite on the productive resources of the American economy and the needs of the American people.  Healthcare in America has now become just such a parasite – the “medical-industrial complex!”

As Dr. Rosenthal astutely observes: “In healthcare, entrepreneurship outsmarts regulation every time.” In the independent political movement, we know this pattern very well.  We’ve learned, for example, that trying to stop the flow of money to Democrat and Republican politicians by campaign finance reform can’t succeed, because new regulations, written by those politicians, come with new loopholes.  The development of new corrupt practices is impossible to keep up with, in both politics and in healthcare, without addressing the question of political power.  We can’t reclaim either our government or our healthcare without creating a new political culture.

Lou Hinman lives in New York City and is an activist with IndependentVoting.org and the New York City Independence Clubs.

Jeff Aron


I won’t say that I “enjoyed” reading An American Sickness by Dr. Elizabeth Rosenthal. It corresponded too closely to experiences of my family and friends – not merely the illnesses and deaths but the difficult engagements with all aspects of a system that creates economic and existential insecurity which have nothing to do with “health.”

Whether based on personal interviews or other research, the stories Dr. Rosenthal shares help us to understand and are devastating critiques of the (mis)organization of healthcare in the United States. So many people are failed by this “system”. I kept wondering what those who supported it might say in its defense. More to the point, I wondered what we as a country would need to do to produce a system(s) other than what we have. What can we do about the overweening power of hospitals, insurance companies, and pharmaceuticals — all of which have enormous political leverage as well as economic incentive to keep things as they are? Would it be possible to build partnerships between those who currently profit from this state of affairs and those who are not served well by it? How might that be organized?

I really appreciated Dr. Rosenthal’s suggestions about what individuals can do. However, I feel similarly to Susan Massad and others who have written that something bolder — more grassroots and more challenging of the larger system of which healthcare is a part — needs to be undertaken.

As I read An American Sickness, from my location as an activist in the mental health arena who also has been a community organizer, I thought of areas of concern and contention in healthcare which might have been more fully explored, e.g., severe mental disorders, aging, and lack of access and education for marginalized groups. While addressing these may not have strengthened the very strong case Rosenthal makes, including these populations as resources would be powerful elements of a movement for change.

I also thought about my brother, my mother, my life partner — all of whom died of serious illnesses — the challenges we faced, the diversity of people we met, the pharmaceuticals that were prescribed, the offices, clinics and hospitals we entered — and how all of us were shaped (deformed) by the economic and political forces that organize the practice of medicine — and everything else in our society. We can and must do better.

Jeff Aron has been active in independent political efforts in New York City and nationally since the late ’70s. He is a passionate supporter of IndependentVoting.org


Politics for the People

Conference Call

An American Sickness

With Author Elisabeth Rosenthal

Sunday, Dec. 2nd at 7 pm EST.

Call in number:  641-715-3605 

Passcode 767775#


Reader’s Forum — Maureen Albanese and Helen Abel

Maureen Albanese

Maureen Albanese

Elizabeth Rosenthal lays out in clear language why our healthcare system got in this sorry state and what we can do to help ourselves get better and cheaper care — but that is not enough.  We must also start electing politicians who will get us to a better healthcare system.  Healthcare should be a right — not a privilege as it is now.  We need to organize our fellow Americans around this issue as we are all but one illness away from homelessness.  This book will be a great conversation starter, but more people need to read it and work together to get the system we deserve.

We can look to France, which has the best healthcare in the world, to help us formulate a better healthcare system.  This healthcare system is not sustainable and until a major overhaul is done America itself will be bankrupt.

Maureen Albanese is an administrative assistant and activist. She lives in Manhattan.

Helen Abel


I found An American Sickness a provocative look at the health care industry and how big profits have been substituted for humane patient care.  Elisabeth goes into great detail about how this has happened and definitely makes a case for the Canadian or Great Britain models of health care.  She also gives tips on how to find out how your hospital rates nationally, where to get drugs more cheaply, and a host of other information.  A good go-to also if you are dealing with a difficult medical situation.

Helen Abel is a Life performance coach and political activist.


Politics for the People

Conference Call

An American Sickness

With Author Elisabeth Rosenthal

Sunday, Dec. 2nd at 7 pm EST.

Call in number:  641-715-3605 

Passcode 767775#


Reader’s Forum — Dr. Jessie Fields

20171104_151329_1509824198579 (1)

Dr. Jessie Fields (center) with Carrie Sackett, Alvaader Frazier, David Belmont and Nardo Reyes –  New York City Independence Club Activists in Harlem doing street outreach.

Health Care Should Be About Health 

I am a community primary care physician. I grew up seeing the effects of social isolation and poverty in the black community and I became a doctor because I wanted to help improve the life conditions of the black poor. Practicing in the poor community, initially on the West Side of Chicago, I soon realized that I had to go outside the walls of the clinic and outside the institution of medicine to be able to work on improving the community’s health.

This lesson is also relevant to the book, An American Sickness: How Healthcare Became Big Business and How You Can Take It Back by Elisabeth Rosenthal. The book is a revealing analysis of the high costs of for-profit medicine as well as an activist guidebook for the American people and patients to confront and change a system that impacts all people.

Those outside the system in partnership with caring health providers I believe can and are making changes. I look forward to our discussing efforts to change the system when we speak with Elisabeth Rosenthal on the conference call on December 2nd. As Rosenthal states in the last few sentences of the book’s Afterward, “…the crusade to take back our health care system…. it’s going to be a long war.”

She documents how American medicine became the highly expensive, wasteful, inefficient complex business designed to generate profit that it is today. Rosenthal tells the story of the beginning of health insurance with Blue Cross and its partner, Blue Shield, which were nonprofit and accepted everyone who sought to sign up. “The original purpose of health insurance was to mitigate financial disasters brought about by serious illness…” Over the subsequent decades, especially through the 1970s and 1980s, “For-profit insurance companies moved in, unencumbered by the Blues’ charitable mission. They accepted only younger, healthier patients on whom they could make a profit. They charged different rates, depending on factors like age, as they had long done with life insurance. And they produced different levels of protection.”

She outlines all the components of the high cost of medicine: insurance, hospitals, pharmaceuticals, doctors, conglomerates, etc. while also focusing on how high costs impact patients.

“Nearly a third of Americans said they had problems paying medical bills, many among those forced to cut back on food, clothing, or basic household items…But will Congress head their distress call? Or will the powerful business of medicine hold sway, as it has for the past thirty years? Time will tell, but there’s a glimmer of hope on the horizon. But that glimmer comes from you, not from Washington.”

Dr. Rosenthal also discusses the benefits and limitations of the Affordable Care Act. Namely that it has increased access to coverage and care but that in the face of the insurance lobbies and partisan political dysfunction, the ACA did not address the high costs of medicine.

Of course, the high costs of medical care are not limited to the money and financial losses by patients and the larger society. The human costs are even more deeply incalculable. The health and well being of patients and families is undermined.

New approaches to healing that involve human compassion and support are needed but not pursued because the focus is how to make a profit from the latest technology. Expensive technology has replaced the hands-on art of a thorough physical examination.

Departments that do not make money such as Obstetrics, especially in medical clinics that serve poor communities, are closed. Pregnant women have limited access to quality prenatal care, resulting in the United States high infant mortality rate — especially relative to other developed countries. The United States spends more than $3 trillion a year on a health care system that is unequal and unjust. We the people have to change it and I look forward to our conversation with Dr. Rosenthal.

Dr. Jessie Fields is a physician practicing in Harlem, a leader in the New York City Independence Clubs, and a board member of the All Stars Project and Open Primaries.


Politics for the People

Conference Call

An American Sickness

With Author Elisabeth Rosenthal

Sunday, Dec. 2nd at 7 pm EST.

Call in number:  641-715-3605 

Passcode 767775#


Dr. Rosenthal on CBS This Morning (Video)

Elisabeth Rosenthal provides tips to drive down medical bills on CBS

From CBS This Morning
November 28th, 2018

In our collaboration with Kaiser Health News and NPR, we’re taking a look at surprise medical bills that catch many Americans off guard. The latest “Bill of the Month” reveals how costly life-saving drugs can be. Shereese Hickson was bedridden with MS symptoms at one point and was prescribed an infusion called Ocrevus. It costs $65,000 a year. Medicare and Medicaid paid for nearly all of her previous treatments, so Hickson was surprised when she was billed more than $3,600 for the first two doses of this new medicine. Kaiser Health News editor-in-chief Dr. Elisabeth Rosenthal joins “CBS This Morning” to discuss the bill.



Politics for the People

Conference Call

An American Sickness

With Author Elisabeth Rosenthal

Sunday, Dec. 2nd at 7 pm EST.

Call in number:  641-715-3605 

Passcode 767775#


Reader’s Forum — PJ Steiner, Steve Guarin, and Jessica Marta

PJ Steiner

An American Sickness: How Healthcare Became Big Business and How You Can Take It Back was recommended to Politics for the People by PJ Steiner. Read on to see PJ’s response to Elisabeth Rosenthal’s book.  


I initially heard about An American Sickness by Elisabeth Rosenthal while listening to an NPR interview with Terry Gross. Dr. Rosenthal was incredibly well versed on what the challenges in our healthcare “system” really are and how those challenges came to be. She absolutely wowed me with her excellent communication skills and journalistic chops.

But unfortunately, I became immediately worried about my own, and my children’s, healthcare future. As a Dad of two awesome autistic children, I worry about how they will be cared for throughout their life. I worry even more because our healthcare system (like public education) doesn’t really want to help them as much as it wants to profit from them.

Now that I’ve had a chance to read Dr. Rosenthal’s book, I feel the true immensity of the amoral “healthcare industrial complex” we have in this country. But I also feel some hope. There are a lot of tools and advice to be had to help the regular American fight their way to better care at a more reasonable cost.

Pick this book up. You’ll be glad you did.

PJ Steiner is the Vice President of The Utah League of Independent Voters.

Steve Guarin


Steve Guarin (r) being presented with a 2016 Anti-Corruption Award by Juliana Francisco

If you want to learn why your wallet is getting lighter and your purse is becoming empty, read An American Sickness by Elisabeth Rosenthal. She lists and explains all the many ways medical care robs your billfold. They will even charge you for things you didn’t use. People have called the billing predatory, which is an outrageous situation to be put in by the people and organizations that are supposed to be helping you.

The subtitle of the story is, “How Health Care Became Big Business and How You Can Take It Back.” In a small part of the book I felt as if she was talking directly at me, the Compliant Patient. Up until I read this book I strived to be a compliant patient. I thought these were the people trying to make me better, but I have learned that is not true. Your family doctor is under a lot of pressure to make use of the expensive facilities of the hospital or medical group that employs him. One type of lab-test which we all get is the simple blood test. It behooves you to ask your doctor to use one of the commercial laboratories, i.e. Quest or LabCorp. It will be exactly the same test but the results from a hospital can be priced one hundred times higher.

Read this book and you will learn how medical care became a rapacious big business. More importantly, the author will teach you to be a Non-Compliant patient, and save some money.

Steve Guarin lives in the Bronx.  He is retired and an activist with the New York City Independence Clubs.

Jessica Marta


As a health-care provider, I’m familiar with many of the issues that Ms. Rosenthal is talking about in An American Sickness. All the unscrupulous things Ms. Rosenthal mentions, particularly price-fixing by pharmaceutical companies, are happening every day.

Is single payer health-care the solution? I don’t know. The single-payer idea has been around since the ’50s. Back then the American Medical Association shot it down by hiring Ronald Reagan to do TV ads telling the American public that single-payer health-care would take away our Freedom of Choice.

If not single-payer, then why couldn’t the government set limits or standards on the price of drugs or medical procedures? Because our government still caters to powerful special interests.

As long as we live under the current paradigm, that making money is the supreme good, poor people won’t have access to good care and middle-class people who can’t afford to pay for their own health insurance will go bankrupt after paying for long-term treatment. But we just see these as consequences for “others” and hope we are never in those situations.

I feel that patients are not the only casualties of our dysfunctional system. There are many providers who go out of their way for patients, jump through bureaucratic hoops to get care, but these folks can get very weary. I don’t know what the answer is, except a shift in political power on behalf of the interests of ordinary people.

Jessica Marta is an independent activist with Independent Voting and the New York City Independence Clubs. She lives in Manhattan and is an Adult Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner.



Politics for the People

Conference Call

An American Sickness

With Author Elisabeth Rosenthal

Sunday, Dec. 2nd at 7 pm EST.

Call in number:  641-715-3605 

Passcode 767775#


Reader’s Forum — Al Bell

A Commentary on An American Sickness: How Healthcare Became Big Business and How You Can Take it Back by Elisabeth Rosenthal

DSC_7664My first question to any elected official I contact about health care legislation (and I will) will be: “Have you read Elisabeth Rosenthal’s book, An American Sickness?”

If the answer is yes, my second question will be: “How have her ideas been incorporated in health care legislation you will sponsor or support?” You can probably imagine the course of the ensuing conversation.

If the answer is no, my second question will be: “Why not?” If the answer is, “I haven’t heard of that book,” or any pathetic derivatives of that answer, I will proceed as follows.

“Here is why you should buy it and read it. Elisabeth presents a comprehensive picture of why and how the medical industrial complex in America mistreats patients, the people we used to believe were the beneficiaries of what we used to think of as our health care system. Patients: that is us. She reveals why and how the complex focuses on profit and not health; why it is a cartel and not a system. She goes on to offer advice on how to work around the obstacles to effective health care despite the non-system by providing information on important sources of aid. She closes by explaining what needs to happen to reclaim a responsive health care system from the piranhas that now call the shots. She reminds us that we have a cadre of superb medical professionals, some of whom have become complicit in this disaster, but most of whom ache to carry out their role as healers and menders to those in need.”

“If you are not willing to read it yourself, then assign it to one of your brightest staff members and insist that she/he communicate with Elisabeth before getting back to you with recommendations on how to proceed. Then contact me and let me know what you intend to do, when you intend to do it, and who else you have joined forces with to make it happen. I especially want to know the names of any in the latter category who are not members of your political party.”

While it may be generally agreed that health care has become a major, if not the major, current concern of Americans, it is also self-evident that the medical industrial complex has shanghaied our political world and inoculated it against any conceivable common sense fix. The same force that is necessary to rescue our dysfunctional federal governance miasma from itself is the one that will turn health care around as well: we the people.

We the people need a tool for opening doors, slamming inattention to the floor, and prying open windows to an approach that will actually work. Elisabeth Rosenthal has given us the pry-bar; it is now up to us to wield it.

Elisabeth is not asking the doctors, specialists, technicians, hospitals, pharmacists, pharmaceutical companies, and others to sacrifice reasonable income and profit. She is making the case that extortion in those areas is not legitimate, especially when we pay with not only our money, but our health outcomes as well.

A message to my 60-some active contacts and my elected (some newly) officials in Arizona urging them to read and act on An American Sickness will go out this week.

Oh, one more thing. Thank you, Elisabeth, for the immense public service you have performed in crafting this report to the American people. Bravo, indeed!

Al Bell lives in Peoria, AZ and is an activist with Independent Voters for Arizona.



Politics for the People

Conference Call

An American Sickness

With Author Elisabeth Rosenthal

Sunday, Dec. 2nd at 7 pm EST.

Call in number:  641-715-3605 

Passcode 767775#


  • Independent Lens

  • Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 353 other followers

  • Featured Links

  • Categories

  • Facebook

  • Links